We Were All New Yorkers On September 12. We're Not All Republicans Now
Upon reading transcripts from last night's RNC kickoff, I remarked, "Rudy Giuliani is going to be assassinated by a 9/11 widow by the end of the week."
Yeah. My FBI file just got that much bigger. Eat me, John Ashcroft.
Read this speech and tell me we were wrong to suspect that the RNC was yet again (ab)using 9/11 for its own political gain by holding its convention in New York.
Or let me read the best parts for you.
Thank you. Welcome to the capital of the world.
Hate to break it to you, Rudy, but New York City isn't even the capital of the state. (Oh, if I can't start off snide...)
And it was here in 2001, in the same lower Manhattan, that President George W. Bush stood amid the fallen towers of the World Trade Center, and he said to the barbaric terrorists who attacked us, "They will hear from us." Well, they heard from us. They heard from us in Afghanistan and we removed the Taliban. They heard from us in Iraq, and we ended Saddam Hussein's reign of terror."
Yes! Saddam Hussein blew up the World Trade Center! Keep telling yourself that.
For the record, he brought up 9/11 less than 50 words into the speech.
Mayor Bloomberg, Governor Pataki, all of you that worked so hard in bringing this convention to New York, our president and the party that decided they'd have it here, above and beyond everything else, it's a statement, it's a strong statement that New York City and America are open for business, and we are stronger than ever.
A statement, a strong statement, that I'm going to throw up if Republicans keep trying to make hay out of September 11.
You know, we're just not going to let the terrorists determine where we have political conventions, where we go, how we travel.
Unless Tom Ridge changes the color of the alert.
From the first Republican president, Abraham Lincoln, to President George W. Bush, our party's great contribution is to expand freedom in our own land and all over the world.
BAHAHAHAHA*PatriotAct*HAHAHAHA!
For me, when I arrived there and I stood below the north tower and I looked up, and seeing the flames of hell emanating from those buildings, and realizing that what I was actually seeing was a human being on the 101st, 102nd floor, that was jumping out of the building, I stood there, it probably took five or six seconds, it seemed to me that it took 20 or 30 minutes, and I was stunned.[...]At the time, we believed that we would be attacked many more times that day and in the days that followed. Without really thinking, based on just emotion, spontaneous, I grabbed the arm of then-Police Commissioner Bernard Kerik, and I said to him, "Bernie, thank God George Bush is our president."
You fucking bastard. You'd better be lying.
President George W. Bush already has earned a place in history as a great American president.
If history is written by alcoholic Texans with learning disabilities.
The attack on the Israeli team at the Munich Olympics was in 1972. That's a long time ago[...]The three surviving terrorists were arrested. And then within just three months, the terrorists who slaughtered the Israeli athletes were released by the German government -- set free.
Jews good! Germans baaaad!
(Hey, I'm German and Jewish. I can say that sort of thing.)
In 1985, terrorists attacked the Achille Lauro. And they murdered an American citizen who was in a wheelchair, Leon Klinghoffer. They marked him for murder solely because he was Jewish. Some of those terrorists were released, and some of the remaining terrorists -- they were allowed to escape by the Italian government because of fear of reprisals from the terrorists.
Jews good! Americans good! Italians baaaad!
So terrorists learned they could intimidate the world community, and too often the response, particularly in Europe
Fuck Europe! These Euro wimps like to have trials instead of sodomizing prisoners. Let's just toss a few grenades into the UN and do our own thing!
Before September 11, we were living with an unrealistic view of our world, much like observing Europe appease Hitler...
Oh, Christ.
Okay, with this much of the speech devoted to demonizing Europe, I can't help but wonder if that's the next stop on the Imperialist Express if Bush gets a second term. If we just take over the EU, we won't have to worry about their opinions...
The president announced the Bush Doctrine, when he said, "Our war on terror begins with al Qaeda, but it does not end there. It will not end until every terrorist group of global reach has been found, stopped and defeated. Either you are with us or you are with the terrorists." And since September 11, President Bush has remained rock solid.
Except when he said "I don't think you can win" the war on terror...then came back a day later and said "we will win." And wait, didn't we already declare "mission accomplished" on this thing?
Jeez, what a flip-flopper...I don't think I can vote for him now...plus he looks kinda German...
They ridiculed Winston Churchill. They belittled Ronald Reagan. But like President Bush, they were optimists.
If Bush thinks our glass is half full at this point, it's only because he doesn't understand fractions.
President Bush will make certain that we are combating terrorism at the source, beyond our shores, so we don't have to confront it, or we reduce of confronting it here in New York City, or in Chicago or in Los Angeles or in Miami or in the rural areas of America.
Like Oklahoma City? Oh, wait, that wasn't the Taliban or the Iraqis...or WAS IT? (Yes, the Defense Department is insane.)
Not a word about jobs, health care, homelessness, poverty, education -- except to say that Middle Eastern governments don't address some of these things very well:
Rather than trying to grant more freedom, or create more income, or improve education and basic health care, these governments deflect their own failures by pointing to America and to Israel and to other external scapegoats
Can WE get some more freedom, more income, better education, and basic health care? Giuliani's whole vision for America is avenging 9/11 by taking over every country with an even worse government than ours. And this is supposed to be the party of optimists?
America can do better. I'm not sure help is on the way, though.
In all seriousness. If anyone should respect the memory of 9/11 victims enough to not turn them into a political talking point, it's Giuliani. He was there. He saw it all. He should know this is a matter not to be trifled with.
Look, I'm from the New York area. Several in my life were affected by September 11, some more tragically than others. And none of them are voting for Bush (Even my most conservative family member, who evacuated lower Manhattan that day and hates the hell out of Kerry, is going to vote Nader or stay home). So let's not tell the rest of the country that Bush owns 9/11. When the people of New York City vote for the dumb prick instead of protesting him en masse, then we can talk.
Upon reading transcripts from last night's RNC kickoff, I remarked, "Rudy Giuliani is going to be assassinated by a 9/11 widow by the end of the week."
Yeah. My FBI file just got that much bigger. Eat me, John Ashcroft.
Read this speech and tell me we were wrong to suspect that the RNC was yet again (ab)using 9/11 for its own political gain by holding its convention in New York.
Or let me read the best parts for you.
Thank you. Welcome to the capital of the world.
Hate to break it to you, Rudy, but New York City isn't even the capital of the state. (Oh, if I can't start off snide...)
And it was here in 2001, in the same lower Manhattan, that President George W. Bush stood amid the fallen towers of the World Trade Center, and he said to the barbaric terrorists who attacked us, "They will hear from us." Well, they heard from us. They heard from us in Afghanistan and we removed the Taliban. They heard from us in Iraq, and we ended Saddam Hussein's reign of terror."
Yes! Saddam Hussein blew up the World Trade Center! Keep telling yourself that.
For the record, he brought up 9/11 less than 50 words into the speech.
Mayor Bloomberg, Governor Pataki, all of you that worked so hard in bringing this convention to New York, our president and the party that decided they'd have it here, above and beyond everything else, it's a statement, it's a strong statement that New York City and America are open for business, and we are stronger than ever.
A statement, a strong statement, that I'm going to throw up if Republicans keep trying to make hay out of September 11.
You know, we're just not going to let the terrorists determine where we have political conventions, where we go, how we travel.
Unless Tom Ridge changes the color of the alert.
From the first Republican president, Abraham Lincoln, to President George W. Bush, our party's great contribution is to expand freedom in our own land and all over the world.
BAHAHAHAHA*PatriotAct*HAHAHAHA!
For me, when I arrived there and I stood below the north tower and I looked up, and seeing the flames of hell emanating from those buildings, and realizing that what I was actually seeing was a human being on the 101st, 102nd floor, that was jumping out of the building, I stood there, it probably took five or six seconds, it seemed to me that it took 20 or 30 minutes, and I was stunned.[...]At the time, we believed that we would be attacked many more times that day and in the days that followed. Without really thinking, based on just emotion, spontaneous, I grabbed the arm of then-Police Commissioner Bernard Kerik, and I said to him, "Bernie, thank God George Bush is our president."
You fucking bastard. You'd better be lying.
President George W. Bush already has earned a place in history as a great American president.
If history is written by alcoholic Texans with learning disabilities.
The attack on the Israeli team at the Munich Olympics was in 1972. That's a long time ago[...]The three surviving terrorists were arrested. And then within just three months, the terrorists who slaughtered the Israeli athletes were released by the German government -- set free.
Jews good! Germans baaaad!
(Hey, I'm German and Jewish. I can say that sort of thing.)
In 1985, terrorists attacked the Achille Lauro. And they murdered an American citizen who was in a wheelchair, Leon Klinghoffer. They marked him for murder solely because he was Jewish. Some of those terrorists were released, and some of the remaining terrorists -- they were allowed to escape by the Italian government because of fear of reprisals from the terrorists.
Jews good! Americans good! Italians baaaad!
So terrorists learned they could intimidate the world community, and too often the response, particularly in Europe
Fuck Europe! These Euro wimps like to have trials instead of sodomizing prisoners. Let's just toss a few grenades into the UN and do our own thing!
Before September 11, we were living with an unrealistic view of our world, much like observing Europe appease Hitler...
Oh, Christ.
Okay, with this much of the speech devoted to demonizing Europe, I can't help but wonder if that's the next stop on the Imperialist Express if Bush gets a second term. If we just take over the EU, we won't have to worry about their opinions...
The president announced the Bush Doctrine, when he said, "Our war on terror begins with al Qaeda, but it does not end there. It will not end until every terrorist group of global reach has been found, stopped and defeated. Either you are with us or you are with the terrorists." And since September 11, President Bush has remained rock solid.
Except when he said "I don't think you can win" the war on terror...then came back a day later and said "we will win." And wait, didn't we already declare "mission accomplished" on this thing?
Jeez, what a flip-flopper...I don't think I can vote for him now...plus he looks kinda German...
They ridiculed Winston Churchill. They belittled Ronald Reagan. But like President Bush, they were optimists.
If Bush thinks our glass is half full at this point, it's only because he doesn't understand fractions.
President Bush will make certain that we are combating terrorism at the source, beyond our shores, so we don't have to confront it, or we reduce of confronting it here in New York City, or in Chicago or in Los Angeles or in Miami or in the rural areas of America.
Like Oklahoma City? Oh, wait, that wasn't the Taliban or the Iraqis...or WAS IT? (Yes, the Defense Department is insane.)
Not a word about jobs, health care, homelessness, poverty, education -- except to say that Middle Eastern governments don't address some of these things very well:
Rather than trying to grant more freedom, or create more income, or improve education and basic health care, these governments deflect their own failures by pointing to America and to Israel and to other external scapegoats
Can WE get some more freedom, more income, better education, and basic health care? Giuliani's whole vision for America is avenging 9/11 by taking over every country with an even worse government than ours. And this is supposed to be the party of optimists?
America can do better. I'm not sure help is on the way, though.
In all seriousness. If anyone should respect the memory of 9/11 victims enough to not turn them into a political talking point, it's Giuliani. He was there. He saw it all. He should know this is a matter not to be trifled with.
Look, I'm from the New York area. Several in my life were affected by September 11, some more tragically than others. And none of them are voting for Bush (Even my most conservative family member, who evacuated lower Manhattan that day and hates the hell out of Kerry, is going to vote Nader or stay home). So let's not tell the rest of the country that Bush owns 9/11. When the people of New York City vote for the dumb prick instead of protesting him en masse, then we can talk.
